While ACD is, of course, best known for the Sherlock Holmes stories, he also left an abundance of other stories to us, many of them quite Gothic and featuring ghosts and mummies and other evil characters.
This edition of Gothic Tales contains 34 short stories of horror and suspense that are not related to the Holmes canon.
As with any collection of short stories, some are better than others.
Btw, all of the stories are available online for free, some are even available as audio narrations on Youtube.
The 34 Stories:
The American’s Tale – 3.5* – fun, in a cryptozoological way
The Captain of the “Polestar” – 4.5* – Wow. So much atmosphere.
The Winning Shot – 3.5* – Necromancy?
J. Habakuk Jephson’s Statement – 2.5* – Interesting but too dragged out, also very dated.
John Barrington Cowles – 4.5* – So good. So dark.
Uncle Jeremy’s Household – 1* – Thriving on Indian mysticism and some stereotyping.
The Ring of Thoth – 4* – spooky
The Surgeon of Gaster Fell – 2* – Boring.
A Pastoral Horror – 3.5* – Haha. Gory, but with a fun twist.
“De Profundis” – 4* – Grim, in a plague way.
Lot No. 249 – 4.5* – Classic, fun mummy horror.
The Los Amigos Fiasco – 4* – Truly grim. A story about electrocution.
The Case of Lady Sannox – 3* stomach turning tale. Also, ironic that the stereotyping backfires.
The Lord of Chateau Noir – 2* – Meh.
The Third Generation – 2* Meh. Medical superstition.
The Striped Chest – 3* – Good, fun, maritime superstition.
The Fiend of the Cooperage – 1* – VERY colonial creature feature.
The Beetle-Hunter – 4* – Atmospheric. This could be at home in the Holmes canon. Also: Brooke Street!
The Sealed Room – 2* – Ghostly.
The Brazilian Cat – 4* – Another one that reads Holmesian in nature. Also: Pernambuco! 😀
The New Catacomb – 3* – another one where archaeology features
The Retirement of Signor Lambert – 2.5* – Operatic ripper story.
The Brown Hand – 2* – Draaaagging on a bit.
Playing with Fire – 3.5* Paranormal fun.
The Leather Funnel – 4* – pure Gothic horror based on historical fact
The Pot of Caviare – 3* – “It was the salmon mousse.”
The Terror of Blue John Gap – 2.5* – too drawn out. Fits with the Lost World.
Through the Veil – 3* – Supernatural Scotland.
How It Happened – 4.5* – Aww. Cute.
The Horror of the Heights – 2* – too much like Lovecraft for me
The Bully of Brocas Court – 3* – Regency bare-knuckle fighting.
The Nightmare Room – 4* – Ha. A very 1920s twist.
The Lift – 2* – Evangelical.
Broken Tune's Blog 
It’s been far too long since I’ve read some of these. And I don’t think I’m familiar with others. One more to add to Mount TBR. lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re up early! Some of these were great, some not so much, but I really enjoyed reading something by ACD that was not connected with the Holmes canon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m almost always up this early. Or earlier. lol. I was looking at my shelf, and the reason some of these were familiar is because I have the collection of Vampire Stories. I think there’s some cross-pollination there. Either way, I need this collection. I agree – it’s a treat to read something else he’s done. I loved reading his Professor Challenger stories.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I still have the Challenger stories and the other series (Sir Nigel, Brigadier Gerard, etc.) to look forward to. 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
There you go!
LikeLiked by 1 person