In One Person - John Irving

I have decided to move on from this one. There is just nothing in this story that keeps me interested, and that is a huge shame because the premise of the book – a coming of age story of a young guy who discovers he is not fitting in with the people around him because of his outlook on life and his sexuality – sounded somewhat intriguing.


I have no idea what to expect, but after just over a third in the book, I just cannot buy into the story or the characters. This is meant to be a tragic comedy, but so far the comedy has escaped me. It does not help that much of the book reminds me of Catcher in the Rye and its protagonist. I could not stand Holden Caulfield. There, I said it. So, having another story centre on a character that seems much like Holden will not work in the book’s favour. Not for me, anyway.


What’s more, none of the other characters seem to be fleshed out (except for old Henry) and so far the construct of personalities that are mostly made up of social stereotypes is just leaving me comparing the book to a number of other books which I would rather be reading.


I take this as a sure sign that it is time to move on.




DNF @ 36%

Original post: